Buying or selling a home is usually the largest financial transaction most people make, and many rely heavily on their realtor along the way. When a realtor gets something important wrong, the financial consequences can be serious. The question many clients then ask is whether they can hold the realtor responsible.
In many cases, the answer is yes. This article explains the duties realtors owe in Ontario, the most common types of claims, and what to do if you think your realtor has cost you money.
What Duties Does a Realtor Owe You?
Realtors and brokerages in Ontario are regulated under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002 (TRESA) and its Code of Ethics, which is administered by the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO). When you sign a representation agreement with a brokerage, you become its client, and the brokerage and its salesperson owe you duties that include:
- acting in your best interests and promoting your interests
- using reasonable care and skill
- giving you accurate information and not misrepresenting material facts
- disclosing material facts they know about, or ought to know about, that affect your decision
- avoiding and properly disclosing conflicts of interest
Apart from the regulatory rules, a realtor can also be liable at common law for negligence, negligent misrepresentation or breach of fiduciary duty.
Common Claims Against Realtors
- Misrepresentation about the property, such as incorrect statements about square footage, zoning, permitted uses, rental income or a basement apartment’s legal status.
- Failure to disclose known problems, such as water damage, a history of the property, or other material facts the realtor knew about.
- Poor advice on the agreement, such as failing to recommend appropriate conditions (financing, inspection or status certificate) or failing to explain the risks of an unconditional offer.
- Conflicts of interest, including undisclosed relationships with the other side or acting in a way that favours the realtor’s own commission.
- Mishandling of deposits or documents that leads to a failed deal.
RECO Complaint or Civil Claim?
Many people start by filing a complaint with RECO. A RECO complaint can lead to discipline of the realtor, but RECO does not award compensation for your losses. If you want to be compensated, you generally need to bring a civil claim, either in the Small Claims Court (for claims up to $50,000) or in the Superior Court of Justice. A RECO complaint and a civil claim can proceed at the same time, and the RECO process does not stop the limitation period for your civil claim.
What Can You Recover?
Damages depend on what the realtor’s error actually cost you. Depending on the facts, this may include the amount you overpaid for the property, the cost of repairs, losses from a failed transaction, a lost deposit, carrying costs and other expenses that flow from the error. You must be able to show that the realtor’s conduct caused the loss, so early documentation is important.
Time Limits
In Ontario, most civil claims must be started within two years of the day you discovered, or ought to have discovered, the claim. Waiting to see how a RECO complaint turns out can put your claim at risk.
What to Do Now
- Gather your representation agreement, listing, agreement of purchase and sale, MLS listing, texts and emails with the realtor, and any inspection reports.
- Write down a timeline of what you were told and when.
- Keep receipts and records of every cost you have incurred.
- Get legal advice early, before the limitation period becomes an issue.
Learn more about our real estate litigation services.
Talk to Z Legal
Z Legal acts in real estate litigation matters across Ontario. Call 647-669-4369 to request a free initial review of your matter.
Martin Zatovkanuk, Managing Counsel, Z Legal Professional Corporation (LSO No. 56680Q)
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Every situation depends on its own facts. If you have a dispute, speak to a lawyer about your specific circumstances.
