A firm agreement of purchase and sale is a binding contract. Still, buyers sometimes fail to close, often because their financing falls through, the market drops, or they cannot sell their own home in time. When that happens, both the seller and the buyer need to understand their rights quickly, because decisions made in the first few days can affect the outcome.
The Seller Must Be Ready to Close
A seller who wants to hold the buyer responsible generally needs to show that the seller was ready, willing and able to complete the deal on the closing date. In practice, the seller’s lawyer usually tenders on closing by delivering the closing documents and confirming that the seller is prepared to complete. Proper tender helps establish that the buyer, not the seller, is in breach.
What Happens to the Deposit?
The deposit is usually held in trust by the listing brokerage. Where the buyer is in breach, the seller is generally entitled to keep the deposit. However, the brokerage cannot simply release it to one side. It will normally release the deposit only on a mutual release signed by both parties or on a court order. If the buyer will not sign, the seller may need to go to court to obtain the deposit.
Can the Seller Claim More Than the Deposit?
Yes. If the seller’s losses exceed the deposit, the seller can claim damages. These commonly include:
- the difference between the original sale price and the lower price the seller later receives on a resale
- carrying costs, such as mortgage interest, property taxes, utilities and insurance, while the property is resold
- additional legal and moving costs and other expenses caused by the failed closing
The deposit is credited against these damages.
The Duty to Mitigate
A seller must take reasonable steps to reduce the loss, which usually means relisting the property promptly and selling at a reasonable market price. A seller who waits too long or turns down reasonable offers may recover less.
What If the Seller Refuses to Close?
The same principles work in reverse. A buyer whose seller refuses to close may claim the return of the deposit and damages, which may include the increased cost of buying a comparable property. In some cases, a buyer may seek a certificate of pending litigation to protect an interest in the property while the dispute is resolved, but this remedy is not available in every case and must be considered carefully.
Time Limits
Most claims arising from a failed closing must be started within two years. Steps to protect a deposit or an interest in the property may need to be taken much sooner.
What to Do Now
- Do not sign any release or new agreement before getting legal advice.
- Keep copies of the agreement of purchase and sale, amendments, closing correspondence and any notices from the other side.
- Track every cost related to the failed transaction.
- Speak to a litigation lawyer as soon as possible.
Learn more about our real estate litigation services. Please note that Z Legal handles disputes and litigation only and does not act on real estate transactions or closings.
Talk to Z Legal
Z Legal acts in real estate litigation matters across Ontario. Call 647-669-4369 to request a free initial review of your matter.
Martin Zatovkanuk, Managing Counsel, Z Legal Professional Corporation (LSO No. 56680Q)
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Every situation depends on its own facts. If you have a dispute, speak to a lawyer about your specific circumstances.
