Being unable to work because of illness or injury is stressful enough. Being told that your short-term disability (STD) benefits have been denied or cut off can make an already difficult situation much worse. A denial is not always the final answer, and there are steps you can take to protect your rights.
Why Short-Term Disability Claims Are Denied
Common reasons for a denial include:
- the insurer says the medical information does not show that you cannot do your job
- forms were incomplete or not submitted on time
- the insurer relies on its own file review or an independent medical assessment
- the insurer says you did not follow recommended treatment
- the condition is said to fall under a policy exclusion
Step 1: Get the Reasons and the Documents
Ask for the denial in writing, a copy of the policy or plan booklet, and a copy of your claim file. The claim file shows what information the insurer relied on and often reveals gaps that can be addressed.
Step 2: Strengthen the Medical Evidence
Many denials turn on the medical evidence. A clear report from your treating doctor that explains your restrictions and how they prevent you from doing the essential duties of your job is often more useful than a short note. Keep attending appointments and following reasonable treatment recommendations.
Step 3: Consider an Appeal, but Watch the Clock
Most insurers offer an internal appeal. An appeal can succeed, but it is not always the best route, and an internal appeal does not necessarily stop the limitation period for a lawsuit. In Ontario, most claims must be started within two years, and the policy may contain its own time limits. Get advice before relying on an appeal alone.
Who Is Responsible: the Insurer or Your Employer?
Some STD plans are insured by an insurance company. Others are self-insured by the employer, with an insurer only administering the claims. If the plan is self-insured, your claim may be against your employer rather than the insurer. Your plan booklet or HR department can usually confirm which applies.
Your Job Is Still Protected
Being on disability leave does not mean your employer can end your employment without consequences. Terminating an employee because of a disability, or failing to accommodate a return to work to the point of undue hardship, may give rise to claims under the Ontario Human Rights Code, and an employee terminated while on leave may also be entitled to notice or severance. A termination while on STD can also affect your access to long-term disability benefits, so it should be reviewed carefully.
Income While You Wait
If your STD benefits are denied, you may be able to apply for Employment Insurance sickness benefits while you pursue your claim. Repayment obligations may apply if you later receive disability benefits for the same period.
How Z Legal Can Help
We review denials of short-term disability benefits, deal with insurers and employers, and pursue claims in court where needed. We also advise on related employment law issues, including terminations and accommodation disputes.
Talk to Z Legal
Z Legal acts in short-term disability and employment matters across Ontario. Call 647-669-4369 to request a free initial review of your matter.
Martin Zatovkanuk, Managing Counsel, Z Legal Professional Corporation (LSO No. 56680Q)
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Every situation depends on its own facts. If you have a dispute, speak to a lawyer about your specific circumstances.
